So we’ve learned that the fourth American Idol judge, Kara DioGuardi (who comes from our home state of NY) is only signed on to American Idol for one year. The question arises, does American Idol need a fourth judge or should they stick with the original trio of Simon, Randy, and Paula? In our opinion, Kara brings an extra flare to the show that it really needed. She has quite the music background with both singing and writing to her credit. So what do you think? Should she stay?